In the aftermath of last week’s somewhat underwhelming Oscars, national treasures The Lonely Island revealed that they had written a song (and created a demo for the corresponding video) for the big ceremony. It was so great and so epic that it was apparently way too expensive to put together, not to mention unrealistic in terms of the star power needed to pull it off. The Oscars sadly passed on it but lucky for us, the dudes decided to share the demo with the world, revealing what would have almost definitely been the best part of the night.
The song features the stars of some of the biggest movies of the year lamenting over the fact that their films often get overlooked when it comes to fancy schmancy awards season. From Wonder Woman to the clown from It to the cavalcade of Hollywood Chrises, the song argues that the often superhuman feats these characters and the people who play them pull off should be considered on the same level as the quieter performances given by frequent Oscar winners, especially because people are actually going to see their movies. It’s hilarious, yes, but it also brings up an incredibly valid point, one that has plagued the Academy for years.
While people who avidly follow the Oscars strive to seek out the films that are recognized by the Academy with a nomination or a win, they’re not exactly the films that are bringing in the big box office dollars. Often, these films are shown primarily in art house theaters and aren’t largely advertised in places where Oscar voters are scarce. As a result people simply don’t see them and don’t have any strong reaction to whether or not they win an award. It can make the Academy seem out of touch with what’s actually hitting with the viewing public, which can result in lower viewership of the ceremony and lower interest overall.
Take, for example, the bit Chris Rock did when he hosted the Oscars in 2005 and 2016. In both instances, he visited a movie theater to talk to average movie goers about the nominees. And in both instances, people didn’t have much to say or much familiarity at all with the films that were actually nominated, but were happy to speak about the “popcorn movies” that they were there to see. It’s played for humor (and it is pretty funny) but it shows that the movies people are actually seeing, the movies people are actually excited about are not the movies getting nominated at the Oscars. It’s why the Oscars expanded the possible number of Best Pictures nominees from five to 10 after “The Dark Knight,” considered to be both a critical and monetary success, lost out on a Best Picture nomination despite eight nominations and one of its stars, Heath Ledger, winning for his unforgettable performance as the Joker in 2009.
This, of course, isn’t to say that every blockbuster film should be in the Oscar conversation. There are plenty of trash movies that make a ridiculous amount of money because some people will just see anything. And it is worthwhile for the Oscars to recognize quieter films that are brilliant despite their lack of moneymaking potential. It can help those films gain more attention and help those filmmakers to get funding for their next project. But there are films that are both artful and money-making that the Oscars can choose to recognize. While I wanted “Get Out” to win best picture this year mostly because it was really really well done and deserved it on that merit alone, it also did incredibly well at the box office. “Dunkirk” also made a lot of money and received plenty of awards recognition. But films like “Wonder Woman” and “Girls Trip,” that provided star performances from the likes of Gal Gadot and Tiffany Haddish and raked in the cash, were left out entirely. Its those kinds of snubs that show the Academy’s blind spots.
With “Black Panther” crossing the $1 Billion mark this past weekend, it has clearly cemented its status and a blockbuster. But it has also been celebrated for the quality of its story, its directing and its performances. If it were to win any award at the Oscars next year it would become the first Marvel Studios movies to receive that honor. Simply a nomination in one of the big categories would be pretty revelatory. But will it happen? Or will The Lonely Island have to make another song next year featuring T’Challa and Co? Only time will tell.
What do you think? Do you think the Oscars should be open to more mainstream films? Are you also a little bit embarrassed by how happy you were to have “American Idol” back on your TV last night? Divulge in the comments. And, of course…
Stay classy.
Jenn